5 Factors to Consider When Searching for the Right Neighborhood


So you checked your credit, assessed the market, and have begun your search for your new home!  You visit all of the listings sites and save your favorite houses, but you realize they are all in different neighborhoods.  And, you’re not actually sure WHERE you want to buy your new home.


How do you know which town or city is right for you?  What factors should you keep in mind when searching for a neighborhood that will meet your needs?  And are there any tools to help you with your search?


Here are 5 factors that you should consider when searching for a new neighborhood.  Most of my Illinois clients are moving to avoid high taxes in their area, and I find myself showing many Northwest Indiana properties as a result.  So, I will use both states as examples throughout this discussion.



While the average commute for Americans is around 27 minutes each way, many people end up traveling 30-60 minutes or more during traffic and construction seasonwhich, as we know, is 365 days a year in Chicago.  If you spend 5 hours of your week in the car, finding a home in a neighborhood with convenient commuting options is crucial for work/life balance.  Consider your average travel time to work, proximity to highways, and public transportation when searching for a home.


Residents of Northwest Indiana who commute to Illinois have heard it before: “You come all the way from INDIANA every day?!”  But the truth is, Northwest Indiana provides great options for commuters to travel to work in a timely manner.


For example, the average driving commute for Dyer residents who work in Chicago is 39 minutes.  Compare that to the 51-minute average drive from Naperville, and you’re saving yourself 2 HOURS of driving time per week!


Do you prefer to take the train to work?  The South Shore Line train has stops in Portage, Hammond, and other Indiana towns, and it provides quiet cars, discounted tickets in bulk, and Wi-Fi.  You’re just a 45-minute ride from downtown at any given time.



Safety can be a big factor in searching for a home.   Whether you have a family or just want to walk the streets worry-free, consider doing some research into each town’s safety rating.


Northwest Indiana provides some of the safest towns to choose from in the entire state.  While Federal Fair Housing laws do not permit agents to discuss neighborhood safety, there are plenty of tools you can use to do the research yourself, including Safewise, Niche, and the National Council for Home Safety and Security.  These lists account for violent and property crime as well as resident reviews.


Often, a good way to research a neighborhood is to drive around at different times (morning, midday, weekdays, weekends, etc.). Doing so gives you an idea of the town’s atmosphere and an opportunity to imagine yourself in that environment. It can also be comforting to see police and fire stations, hospitals, and other emergency resources are close by.



Benjamin Franklin once said that there are two certainties in life: death and taxes.  Taxes are a huge factor in your new monthly home payment, and knowing what to expect when it comes to federal, state, and county taxation is key to budgeting accordingly.


There are several tools you can use to research the taxes you might pay in different areas.  Financial website Kiplinger provides a detailed map showing the difference in taxation among US states:


Neighborhood tax map at state level


Likewise, you can compare state-to-state taxes with their list tool, as I have done here with Illinois and Indiana:


Neighborhood tax statistics: Illinois and Indiana


The area in which you choose to buy a home can affect your buying power.  For Illinoisans looking to move to Indiana, the difference in buying power can be significant thanks to lower taxes.  For example, a budget of $180,000 in parts of Illinois can equate to a $230,000 budget if searching in Indiana!  Understanding how tax percentages play into your house payment can change which homes you can afford in different neighborhoods.



If you have children, education is a category you should research.  Take a look at schools in each neighborhood, paying attention to academics, student programs, and athletics (if applicable).


Northwest Indiana provides some great schools, and there are plenty of tools to help you pick a district.  Niche compiles school lists based on data involving graduation rates, college readiness, teacher quality, and more, and U.S. News provides “Best High School” rankings that include some Indiana schools.  


If you’re looking to provide a stellar elementary, middle, or high school education for your childor all of the aboveNorthwest Indiana has wonderful options for schooling in each neighborhood.


Social Needs

When searching for a home, consider neighborhoods that can provide you the excitement you need.  Whether you’re extroverted or introverted, search for areas with the right amount of social interaction for your comfort level.


Do you prefer a tight-knit community where everything is within walking distance?  You can use sites like Walk Score to gauge an area’s walkability and see how close your potential home is to local restaurants, shops, parks, etc.


When it comes to towns that offer social events in Northwest Indiana, you really can’t go wrong with any neighborhood.  From weekly activities to holidays, each one hosts events throughout the year. Just take a look at this list of “20+ Places to See Santa Claus in Northwest Indiana” posted by local blog Ramble the Region.


If you require retail therapy regularly, the areas surrounding Southlake Mall in Hobart and Shops on Main in Schererville are filled with shopping opportunities at major retailers.  Many townssuch as Valparaiso and Crown Pointeven have downtown areas made up of small businesses you can support.


In Summary

Commute, safety, taxes, education, and social needs are important factors to consider when searching for a new home.  Although the importance of each factor can vary from person to personsomeone with children may prioritize education and safety over taxes or commutethese categories encompass many of the circumstances individuals should consider when searching for a town or city that can meet their needs.


My Home Search App is a great tool to use when searching for the right neighborhood in which to buy a home.  The best part: if you open the Home Scan feature, point your phone at any house for sale, and tap the screen, the app can provide you more info with no search required.


Contact me today if you have any questions regarding the right neighborhood for you and your family!



Posted on December 7, 2019 at 12:40 am
Bob Showalter | Category: First Time Homebuyers Guide, Uncategorized | Tagged , ,